Songwriting Zen - What Is A Bad Song Anyway?

Yeah! What is a bad song anyway?

I ask this question because it seems to me that we, as songwriters are experts at naming which one of our creations are 'bad'. So much so that, for some songwriters it stops them from creating altogether.

Here are some thoughts I have on the subject...

I don't know, call me strange but I personally don't look at my songs as being either good or bad. They just are.

At the end of the day I put my songs into one of two categories:

1. Songs I perform
2. Songs I don't perform

Of course the songs that I perform are pieces that I am very comfortable with sharing with the listening public and/or other musicians

The songs I don't perform can then go into one of two more categories:

1. Works in progress (to be completed for performance)
2. Archived songwriting ideas (for later)

I never throw anything away. Everything that comes from my head is created into something or recycled to be created into something else.

Lets face it. The more songs you write, the more 'good' songs you write. I reckon that for every good song written there are (at the very least) 10 'bad' ones lurking in the wings.

So, no matter how much you think your songwriting ideas are lame, just write them down. Besides, where is the rule that says you have to pitch or perform every song that you write anyway?

If you want to write 'good' songs then bad songs are inevitable and besides, what makes a song bad? One songwriters bad song could perhaps be another performers treasure. What do you think?

There are going to be some songs that you write that are the equivalent of a singer warming up before a performance. Some songs are meant to be performed and some songs are but stepping stones towards the songs that are meant to be performed.

When you think about it, the concept of a song being 'bad' is created from a subjective opinion and really, is proclaiming one of your songs as being bad your call anyway?

I mean, I know when I finish writing something I have to step away for a bit to get a different perspective because at the point of finishing a song I'm way too close to it to make any judgements on it whatsoever.

We, as songwriters through observation and mindfulness accumulate songwriting ideas and miscellaneous tidbits in our heads but, if we don't empty our minds by writing all of that accumulated stuff down how can we create any more space for new songwriting ideas to enter into?

Here is a songwriting exercise to try on yourself. Try deliberately writing a 'bad' song and see how you go. It would be like asking a seasoned musician to play like a beginner. It's actually harder to do than you think.

Just a thought...

Until next time, happy writing,

Corey Stewart
Singer/Songwriter/Musician
www.coreystewartonline.com
www.orangutangmusic.com
www.myspace.com/coreystewart

While you're here you might as well check out my other blogs
The Bizzo - Indie Music Industry Tips
Recording Studio And Live Music Tips

Download my FREE eReport today
11 Ways To Eliminate Writers Block FOREVER!!

Keywords: songwriting process, songwriting tip, songwriting, song writing, singer songwriter, songwriting news, songwriting idea, songwriting help, songwriting blog, corey stewart

Comments

Jana wrote:

Awesome post! I agree, and many times I've had a "bad" song get itself out of my system, and then I took one line from it that sparked something, and wrote a keeper from it. But the keeper never would have existed without the bad song. :) Thanks for the reminder...
Sunday 10 June 21:43

Jeff wrote:

Cory, I just discovered you blog. Nice!

I would argue that songs can be bad just like any other piece of art. Sure, it's subjective, and you never know what people will like, but I think that's why popular and good are two different things. Dylan's Shelter From The Storm is a good song, Muscrat Love is a popular song. Wouldn't you agree that Dylan's tune is better? As for bad songs, man, I think there are tons out there and that they're easy to write. Here, I'll jot a quick one:

SUNSET ON US

The sun sets over the pale sand
Bathing us in light as we hold hands
No words spoken, there's no more trust
For tonight it's sunset on us

We met years ago in a small town
Through it all we've had ups and downs
And though we thought our dreams would never turn to dust
It's sunset on us

Are hands separate so very slowly
We're giving in, we're getting free
And though we once burned with love
It's sunset on us

Cliché, no? Bad, yes?
Monday 16 April 13:39

Add Comments

:

:
:

:




Required for non-registered users